I would go with much more powerful power supplies. In constant use a power supply can easily loose 30% of its output after one year. I wouldn’t use less than 750 watts. We have burned out 550 watt power supplies in or render farm. Nothing over 650 has burned out. Spring for the 90plus Gold efficiency if you really plan on using your farm. This will save you on electricity later (never did the math to see if it would actually save you money, but it will reduce your carbon footprint, assuming it doesn’t take more energy to MAKE the more efficient supplies.) Note these are all ATX power supplies. We use 4U servers with ATX power supplies because they are easy to replace, easy to find, and last longer than smaller PSUs in smaller cases. Yes, this takes up more rack space, but we have the physical space.
We have been using the Sabertooth boards from Asus. They have been reliable (as have the P6T deluxe boards). These machines have seen a lot of use. They are overclocked, and they run hot.. In other words, they are abused.. The only thing that ever failed was power supplies (550W Thermaltakes to be precise, burned three or four of those in a year).
Cooling is critical, and will also be one of your biggest expenses power-wise. If this is a home setup I would consider putting them in the basement, but ventilation is important. These will generate a lot of heat when rendering.
I would use Windows 8, not 7.. Why? I hate 8 as much as most people, but it will be supported longer. Microsoft learned their lesson in not making profit with XP. They supported it WAY too long, and I predict they will start retiring OSes much faster. Why take the time to install and set up an OS that is already obsolete? Autodesk just broke XP64 for 2014 SP1.
The newer OS will last much longer. With render nodes you want to keep them as long as you can (until their power usage doesn’t justify using them any more as chips become more efficient). We had to upgrade some XP64 machines to work with 2014 Sp1. They were many years old, but still powerful (these were former workstations that had migrated into the farm). The point is that the hardware may still be in your farm by the time the OS is no longer supported by Microsoft or AutoDesk. Definitely best to go with the latest OS now. Once you get past the “Why the hell does it work like that!?” and “Where the hell is feature X?!?” with Windows 8 it is actually pretty nice. And 8.1 is coming soon as a free upgrade to at least bring a Start button back (not sure if there will be a Start MENU, which is what is needed).
If possible make all the machines the same. A homogenous farm is very helpful when things break. It makes it easy to diagnose by swapping parts out.
We keep a spare power supply on hand at all times. I would suggest the same. These are the things that fail…
Consider Western Digital green drives for their lower power usage. With three machines it may not be a big deal, but once you have 10, 20, 100 nodes it becomes a big deal.
Good luck!