How to block light by using V-Ray Shadow Catcher but make shadow still affect alpha?

V-Ray V-Ray for 3ds Max General
1

Now light is go through Shadow Catcher objects.
These are settings and scene’s details:

image.png
image.png1338×786 130 KB

Result:
image.jpg
image.jpg817×890 98 KB

I think cause this problem was light direct go through the Shadow Catcher objects,​​​
image.jpg
image.jpg1029×898 33.9 KB
​​
image that inside Red Square should be dark like this:
image.jpg
image.jpg1006×881 121 KB

image.png
image.png814×891 14.8 KB

But when I got this result, shadow was not affect alpha,
​So, the problem is, How can I get that perfect shadow and correct lighting at the same time?

2

Would you be able to send me the shadow catcher geo, saved within the same file you’ve shown here?
I can do without the character. :slight_smile:

3

I will send the files to your email. Please pay attention to your email.

4

Have you checked your email?