Hi team, I am a new-ish user to Blender/Vray, and thanks for all the work that’s gone into this. V-Ray is incredibly capable, and when it’s set up right, the results are great.
I’ve worked in 3D and used everything for nearly 30 years, and I wanted to share some workflow feedback that comes up in my day-to-day studio work across most renderers.
The main issue
A lot of common tasks feel like 90% setup just to get the feature “to work.” Things like dome lights and Shadow caster materials often require a bunch of manual node wiring and many clicks before you can even begin using the tool to get a result. (mentioned this at BCON)
That part is not creative work. It is time spent on labor.
A simple way to think about it
- Meaningful work: choices that affect the final image (lighting direction, intensity, mood, material response)
- Labor: repeated, predictable setup steps (adding obvious image nodes, connecting the same chains every time, clicking through the same steps just to reach a usable baseline)
Labor Example:
- Adding a thing
- Moving a thing
- Connecting an image node to something that obviously needs an image (shaders)
It takes longer to add, connect, and load an image than it takes to get a result with the light!
Example: Dome light should ship ready
If I create a Dome Light, I would love it to be immediately usable:
- An obvious HDR slot is already there and connected
- A quick “load HDRI” action
- The scale is automatically set
- Reasonable defaults dialed in to each DCC, so it renders immediately, so we don’t have to “fix” it to get the result
Artists should not have to build the same “starter wiring” every time for something that is implied by the tool itself. A very similar situation with a Shadow Caster. These are all a string of connectivity steps that should just be a one-click setup that wastes time and can be automated.
What I’d love to see
- Smart defaults that produce a valid result immediately
- Auto-connecting for the obvious stuff, while still showing the underlying nodes for people who want more control
- Fewer clicks, fewer connections, and less setup that doesn’t take 90% of the UX to get a result
- Tracking UX improvements with simple metrics like time to first render, # of clicks to working, and connections to working material
- Why not include a Light Template Scene in “Rendering”, that includes all the features you need, with checkboxes to toggle on/off what you need, so you can immediately start lighting vs manually adding, placing, and building a scene from scratch. Yes, we can buy and build our own templates, but why not just offer this to us? It is the same, and there is a “standard”
This is meant with respect for the engine and the team. I just want to spend more time making creative decisions and images, and less time doing manual setup that the software can predict and handle.
Thank you!
Dave
Submitted on AHA Ideas (VBLENDER-I-70).