Light Management UI Improvements/Requests

Status: new

Hi team, just a few ideas/requests after recently working with the Light Management feature:

  • Why does editing multiple lights require going into a specific ‘multi select’ mode? Why can’t I just shift+click or box select multiple lights when in the normal light management mode? The two modes seem like they would be way better merged into one, they’re 99% the same thing.
  • Are there plans to introduce “groups” for light objects? It would be incredibly handy to be able to create (and save) custom groups and then assign lights to that group. Lights should probably be able to belong to multiple groups, but I haven’t thought that far ahead… In general though it’s pretty tedious if I have 8x accent lights and I change the colour for artistic effect, and then I want to tweak the colour later and I have to go back and select them all individually again. Being able to click a group name and having all lights in that group auto selected would be handy.
  • If there were somehow a way to then transfer groups across presets I think that could be beneficial. Maybe a setting when creating the group for “global group” (displays in all presets) or “preset only group” (only exists in that preset).
  • Enscape allows light object names to be individually edited, and it also allows multiple light objects to have the same name. E.g. I can rename 5x light objects to “Bedroom Downlight”. Given this is the case, why can’t the multi-edit workflow also allow renaming? Currently, it says the name is “mixed” and it’s greyed out. If names can be edited, and multiple objects can have the same name, then I should be able to rename multiple lights at the same time.
  • I’d like to request for Light Object names to be transferrable across presets. I can see how it might not please everyone all of the time, so to get around that the configuration for Light Objects could just have two name properties: “Global Name: …” and “Preset Name: …” ?
  • When hovering over the light object in the sidebar it would be great if that light object would also highlight in the model. Currently, only the selected light is highlighted. Adding an additional highlight in the model to correspond to the light object being hovered over in the sidebar would make selections and identifications way easier.
  • In the edit light object pop-up window, if a value has been modified then the “Reset to CAD Defaults” option/button should always be displayed imo, not only on hover. It’s way too annoying when working with a Light Object to tell at a glance which values have been edited. There should be some visual indication of which values are being manually managed.
  • Similarly, in the list of Light Objects in the side bar, it would be handy if lights that have been modified were also visually distinguished somehow. Trying to manage the presets over a project life quickly becomes unmanageable when there are multiple users, accidental duplications, presets not actually doing anything custom, etc. It’s a lot easier/nicer from a model management point of view if I can click through the presets and get a general indication of exactly what the preset is controlling, how much it’s actually doing, whether it can be safely deleted, etc.

Hey @Grey_Block , thanks for one more detailed post, please keep them coming! :slight_smile:

Good news first: we are working on the next round of Light Management improvements and we will consider the smaller points within that effort: selecting multiple lights without a separate mode, highlighting the light in the model when you hover it in the list, and seeing at a glance which values and which lights were edited. For the last two I’m not sure yet how easy they are to implement, so no promises on those.

Regarding grouping lights: it’s a bigger topic that we can’t handle this quarter, but we would like to work on it in 2027. No date yet, it is on the plan, and once we’re there I’ll let you know.

One question on the names: when you rename a light, the name is only kept in the preset you’re in. To keep the same names across presets you can use “duplicate the preset” functionality, does that address your need? If not, could you tell me a bit more about when you rename lights and switch presets, so I understand the situation?

The last part about managing presets over a project lifetime is a complex topic (to be honest, presets in general), I noted it but can’t promise an update about it soon.

No problems, thanks for the response!

Duplicating the preset is fine if all lights have been placed and no more are going to be added in future, but if a preset already exists and then new light objects are added later on it can get a bit messy is all. If I was able to add new light objects to the scene and then name them “Kitchen LED Strip” or “Garage Uplighting” or whatever, and have this name pushed to the existing presets then it would make it easier.

It’s maybe more of an issue for us due the setup of our lighting families and nested light sources, perhaps the root cause of the issue is just that the default CAD name doesn’t really help me a great deal in identifying exactly what and where the light object is. So renaming it globally would help (us) out. (But so would just being able to save a bunch of unnamed lights into a group.)