Mental ray user with a couple of questions

Hello everyone

Yesterday i tried out Corona for the first time. Well, i just run benchmark scene, but seeing how fast it rendered i had to test it further.
I dug out an old scene i once used to test Vray against Mental, to see how Corona works. Since i know nothing about it’s options (i see same lingo as in Vray, so i gues Vray users are in luck there), so i left everything at default, just switched secondary solver to HD cache, as Rawalanche suggested in one post about interiors.

Here are the results. Mental rendered in 33:04, Corona did 22 passes in 33:13.

Mental ray:


Corona:


Beside different color cast (sun in both renderer is set from sky), and considerably grainier Coronas render, there are a couple of other things like missing fine detail shadows, and some strange shadows.

Here are they highlighted with Mental ray cutouts:


Materials are relatively simple, i don’t think i messed up there (i hope i didn’t :smiley: ), so what could be the problem? What settings should be tweaked to get better results, and get them, if not faster, at least in the same time? Considering how fast that benchmarks scene popped out, something must be “wrong” in my scene.

Here are both scenes, if someone would be so kind to take a stab at it:

Corona:
https://app.box.com/s/h68fz09k2s3cy7n2e0wb

Mental:
https://app.box.com/s/3rqai98f4nbvq8zqepun

Thanks in advance!

Quite possible, what about the speed? What can be done to speed things up and get cleaner render in less time? Or is it unreasonable to expect both better, and faster, from an unbiased renderer?

I had a quick look on your scene:

  1. put a portal in both of the windows, you were using 1 which was not quite well aligned, the other window was portal-free
  2. walls could be a bit less bright, they are at rgb 215 atm, I’d go for 180 maybe.
  3. more subdivisions for the couch and the jagged shadows will be gone :wink: It’s a problem related to smoothing and not enough subdivs
  4. as rawalanche said, shadows are quite fine for the fabric, but this material was also quite high, maybe you’ll be more pleased with the results if you lower the brightness.

On purpose, because MR scene also has only one portal.

  1. walls could be a bit less bright, they are at rgb 215 atm, I’d go for 180 maybe.

Agreed.

  1. as rawalanche said, shadows are quite fine for the fabric, but this material was also quite high

Yes it is, honestly, i remember when i first created that scene there was a reason why i left all of materials with diffuse level at 1 (which i usually never do), but now, i have no idea why :smiley: But for testing purposes i also left all of Corona diffuse levels at 1.

For the speed issue… I disabled bitmap paging in your scene and the rays/s shot up from 600.000 to nearly 3.000.000 :smiley:
I guess this may help a bit

maybe it’s not a big deal with MR using only 1 portal (I don’t know mr very well) but it’s not quite useful to do so in corona - it’s possible but it won’t help so much getting rid of noise.

Damn, how did i miss that, it shouldn’t be enabled in the first place :confused:

That’s a new one for me as well :smiley: (i never have it enabled).

and i will post the result once i am finished :slight_smile:

Thank you very much! Looking forward to experiment with it, i’m currently applying changes DeadClown suggested.

EDIT:
Damn! 15 minutes in and i stopped it, it was there, same quality as MR. I knew bitmap paging slowes things down, but i didn’t expect it to have that much of an impact.


Now, to see what MR does to this scene with paging off.

EDIT2:

Even after i added more sudivs, shadows are still jagged. Is this a bug, or a known “problem” that is not actually a problem but just the way Corona works?


The odd bump behaviour is my only problem with Alpha5 which I use currently. The jaggednes might also be the terminating error with unbiased method as mentioned above.

Regarding lack of contact shadows, sometimes they indeed are too meager, although it might be quite correct behaviour, pure PT+PT does help slightly even if 4096 PT subdivs are used in HDCache (I always use 4096 for finals) but of course that is not the best thing to do in interiors and Corona is largely built around this as main feature. [my white wall is between regular RGB150! to 180 if it’s supposed to be quite new/white :- ) ]

In this case bump is a mix of celular and bitmap, both are blured to 1.

right now i am at office doing weekend shift

I’m very sorry to hear that :smiley:

so result wont be sooner than this evening :slight_smile:

No problem, there’s no rush. In the menatime, considering they are named similarly, are Coronas HD cache and Path tracing at all similar to Vrays Light cache and Path tracing? Would it help to watch some Vray tutorials on Light cache and path tracing to better understand Coronas settings/theory and what’s going on behind them?

This is going down in my notebook :smiley: Thank you!

Thank you very much! Tomorrow i’ll have some time to dig in to it, and then i’ll probably have more questions :smiley: