Not expected shadow behavior with Matte Shadow Receiver

There is this behavior that I think it is not life-like:
When rays of a light are completely obstructed, they cast shadows that should not be casted. I found out this behavior when using a rectangle light with directionality value of 1 and an infinte plane with Matte_shadow_receiver, but after making some tests, activating shadow render elements, using other materials and changing the directionality values, I think it is inherent in how shadows are calculated. This creates out of this world images and is specially problematic when creating PNG with shadows using Matte_shadow_receiver and in postproduction.

The behavior is highly noticeable when using a matte shadow receiver material and using high directionality values for rectangular lights or spotlights (as far as i know), but the issue is visible when looking at render elements. It is as if the shadows are calculated as a projection, instead of as a lack of projection of light (It is the best way i can think of it)

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1FcMnPGZWdOhw\_LDpPl9u0DLtmeeUVwL6?usp=sharing

Update your browser to use Google Drive - Google Drive Help

Hi estraulino,

This looks like a V-Ray Core bug.
I was able to reproduce the same in V-Ray for Maya:

I’ll investigate further and create an issue for it.
Thank you for reporting it!
Konstantin

Hi,

Yeah, I found that issue in Rhino too, but I didn’t know where should I post it. Where should I post if I find issues in multiple versios of vray?
I reported this issue in our bug tracking system.
There is no need for you to do anything additional.

I found another weird behavior related to light directionality. If there is a rectangular light (It does NOT happen with disc lights) with a Directionality value higher that 0.75 behind a glass material, the light behind the glass dims substancially. At a directionality of 0.8 it is almost completley dimmed, and when the value hits 1, there is no light. Even if the intensity value is incredibly high.
This looks like a bug.
It used to be that even without refraction, the dimming would happen. This was fixed at one point.
What you’ve described is a left over issue.
I’ll report it as a bug.

Regards,
SketchUp