comparison renders

[phildlight]

I saw this over on the maxwell forum. That whole thing is really getting annoying. The maxwellians still want to say that they can compare that bloated beast of a render engine to other production engines. You can't! It's not usable in production. Anyway, somebody there posted this image, with no explanation or specs on the renders. Just said. Comparison render at 20 minutes. That's a crock of you know what!

[percydaman]

haha lovely. compairing a non biased renderer, rendering with hits native method(maxwell), to another renderer (vray) who's nonbiased method is practically a thrown in toy. Honestly's if vray's image had less noise then maxwell's, the uproar would have been stupendous.

Oh, and I thought maxwell incorporated some sort of noise reduction into its renders as well.

[jujubee]

"Dear Maxwell User,

Please post your scene so we can show you how to use Vray."

[CCS]

No kidding. Vray's image is obviously sabotaged. My favorite part is the BusyRay render. IMO, it looks better than Maxwell! And the price difference....

Why would I buy Maxwell again?

[phildlight]

This was my response.

I don't understand. DId you render each scene in the engine labeled? If so, why are they grainy? I've never seen other engines produce grainy results unless the person who setup the render didn't understand the settings. Also, are you suggesting that each one took 20 minutes to render? Can you expand your explanation of the settings for each, machine specs etc.? Thanks.

This was his!

the calculation has been activated with,
therefore 4 render at the same time
not arriving to a noise acceptable.

[Paul Oblomov]

If somebody want to ask about scene or whatever
http://www.maxwellrender.com/forum/v...tion+activated

[RErender]

BusyRay Rules!

[phildlight]

If somebody want to ask about scene or whatever
http://www.maxwellrender.com/forum/v...tion+activated

Although, judging from his response, I don't know what good it will do to ask.

[jujubee]

I think this would be his response:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...ch+recognition

[phildlight]

Look at this new post! WTF? He is obviously just trying to make the vray render look bad. B.S.!

http://www.maxwellrender.com/forum/v...ic.php?t=18127

[pengo]

I know ISMA and He is not for one engine against another especially against vray he likes to tests the ngines to find the most precise or the one u like more as anyone of us would do.
I can have the scene but He proposes to do tests and explaining the parameters and technique

in next msg i'll pos his scene I'm uploading it

[Paul Oblomov]

Nice. Waiting

And would be great, if you tell us his PC specs.

edit

BTW - lower your monitor gamma - I can clearly see some regular patterns on walls.

[Paul Oblomov]

So ?

[pengo]

scene here:
http://rapidshare.de/files/29391483/...flash.zip.html
textures here:
http://rapidshare.de/files/29398427/textures.zip.html

he used PPT to calculate vray solution with a vraylight at windows

he used dual opteron 265 and about RAM 4 GigaBytes

Me and him will wait the tests of the interested vray users

[jujubee]

Someone should just smack this down with a straight LWF render.