Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Dual xeon system

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Dual xeon system

    Hello Guys

    I have a technical question which is closely related to vray.

    I purchased 3x970 Gtx cards last year because I thought that vray rt render is going to be faster with 3 gpu cards instead of one cpu. (based on all the tech videos on the net) I have done loads of testing after I had a few forum conversation how to make it work.

    Cuda render works fine now with the latest nightly build. However I am not satisfied with the speed of it. Its probably my fault that I was fooled by the gpu render tech demos on youtube and all the articles about how much faster gpu renders will be and "the future of rendering is gpu" etc.. or I couldn't afford a 3000 dollar Titan, I could only buy nvidia 970s.

    I might have done something wrong, despite of the fact that I tested lot of scenes, but its always kinda the same speed for me with the 3 gpu cards like when Im using my cpu. (i7 - 5930k) The problem is the noise in the shadow areas, they never seem to go away only in the most simple scenes. I've got the an almost final image in a few sec then I have to wait 10 minutes for the noise level to go down.

    Its not only the speed of course, the stability of the system and the software was far from cpu render as well.

    Vlado here once told me that the time of cpu render is far from over, and I beginning to believe that now. So I've decided that instead of a 3 way SLI I now change it to a dual CPU system with xeons. I've done an extensive research on dual xeon systems, I've already put together an affordable dual cpu system as well, I just want to hear what you guys think of this idea before purchase. They say more cores with slightly lower frequency is better for rendering that is why xeon cpu is a good choice.

    Please if anybody here has some experience or advice on this subject dont hesitate to share it, and I know it might be a noob topic so you dont need to remind me about that

    Thanks very much!
    CPU: 5930K
    GPU: 3x970 GTX,
    MEM: 32 GB ram
    SSD

  • #2
    i had a similar problem some months ago and decided to buy two 10 core xeons with lower frequency instead of two 8 cores with higher frequency... in my opinion it was a bad decision.... there are still so many single core tasks in the daily workflow that i think it is better to get less cores but a higher frequency for the same amount of money...

    Comment


    • #3
      Thanks for your answer. Well my only hope is that it will be faster and more stable than what I have now with the 3x970 gtx gpus. Im planning to buy two 2630-v3 xeon cpus, with 16 cores and 32 threads. Should be enough..
      CPU: 5930K
      GPU: 3x970 GTX,
      MEM: 32 GB ram
      SSD

      Comment


      • #4
        I currently have two E5-2670V2 - Which are 10 Cores - It is fantastic, rendering is actually a fun experience and essentially you can paint with buckets.

        As for single threaded tasks there are a few, but I haven't noticed any major slow down on single threaded performance as I mainly render in Vray.
        Ashton Woolley
        Senior CGI Generalist

        ASHTONWOOLLEY.COM

        Comment


        • #5
          Thanks!

          Isnt there any compatibility problem with vray or any kind of other software?

          Are there any more advantages on a xeon based system? Like more stability or something?
          CPU: 5930K
          GPU: 3x970 GTX,
          MEM: 32 GB ram
          SSD

          Comment


          • #6
            Hmmm - Not sure about the whole "More Stable" claims.... Do be honest I think the major benefits are that only Xeon's can be doubled for a Dual CPU machine, and that they have a large Max Memory Bandwidth and Cache.

            Apart from that they also support ECC Ram which is used for servers - People in our industry only buy some for the power of having two CPU's in one machine!
            Ashton Woolley
            Senior CGI Generalist

            ASHTONWOOLLEY.COM

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by AshtonWoolley View Post
              Hmmm - Not sure about the whole "More Stable" claims.... Do be honest I think the major benefits are that only Xeon's can be doubled for a Dual CPU machine, and that they have a large Max Memory Bandwidth and Cache.

              Apart from that they also support ECC Ram which is used for servers - People in our industry only buy some for the power of having two CPU's in one machine!
              Thats what Im trying to do I wanted to do it with gpu cards.. apparently it was not enough.. Thanks for all your help!
              CPU: 5930K
              GPU: 3x970 GTX,
              MEM: 32 GB ram
              SSD

              Comment


              • #8
                have a look here :
                http://forums.chaosgroup.com/showthr...827#post648827
                3LP Team

                Comment


                • #9
                  Used to be that you had to go to program files->Chaosgroup->Vray RT...->Select OpenCL devices for V-Ray RT GPU

                  Maybe that's not set properly? Was my problem once, though I'm not sure if it's still needed.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Select open cl is still needed even with cuda, although by default it's using all of the cards if it has never been setup.

                    Stan
                    3LP Team

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X