Visible in reflections uncheck issue

[gagui]

Hi.
I'm having an unexpected problem dealing with the reflection and refraction rays of one plane. I need this plane visible in refractions to be seen through the bottle but not seen in the reflections of other objects.
The problem is I uncheck visible in reflections for the plane and it is still visible in the other metallic objects although this plane has "cast shadows" and "visible to GI" unchecked aswell.

So making some test I found that if I uncheck "visible in refractions" the plane disappears from metallic objects and bottle.
Maybe a bug?

[hermit.crab]

I cannot seem to reproduce the issue. Simply disabling the "Visible in reflections" works as you would like. Maybe there is something else causing the issue. Could you attach the scene (or a simplified version of it) here so we can take a look?

[gagui]

Sure, here it is.

[hermit.crab]

The reflections in the provided scene are correctly disabled. See this gif (made the plane green for clarity; comparison between Visible in Reflections on/off). If you're referring to the black stripes on your metallic objects (screencap attached in your first post) as the issue - they are caused by the objects' overlap with the plane.