Linear workflow tickbox with VrayLightDome texture

[snivlem]

Hi,

I understand that Linear workflow tickbox is not the preferred method, probably because of the following (ie confusion);

If I have the Linear workflow tickbox on and a HDRI and it is assigned to the VRayLightDome. What gamma setting should I be using on the texture for correct results?

I can't decide if the HDRI should be .454 or 1?

Anyone know?

[tashko.zashev]

Hi,

It depends on your linear workflow. If you use the "Linear workflow" option the HDR file used in V-ray Dome light will not be gamma corrected (with 0.454). So with gamma 2.2 value added to the color mapping section (i assume that you are using this value), the rendered HDRI will be shown in Gamma 2,2 (HDR is in linear color space). For this case if sRGB button is ON, the HDR will be double gamma corrected, otherwise the texture will be gamma 2,2.

The settings should be different in case that linear file from VFB need to be saved. The HDR texture needs to be gamma corrected (.454).

[vlado]

HDR and OpenEXR textures should NEVER be gamma corrected (except for artistic purposes) regardless of whether you use linear workflow or not. Especially when they are used in lights - the lights work with actual physically linear units and they expect the textures to be in linear physical space too.

Best regards,
Vlado

[snivlem]

Thank you both for clearing that up.

[sharktacos]

Perhaps I've misunderstood, but it seems to me that Tashko is saying
YES, the HDR on the light should have a gamma correction (.455)
and Vlado is saying
NO, the HDR on the light should not have a gamma correction

So which is it guys?

[vlado]

and Vlado is saying NO, the HDR on the light should not have a gamma correction. So which is it guys?

No, it should not have gamma correction.

Best regards,
Vlado