New Fake or Foto

V-Ray V-Ray Common Off-topic
1

http://area.autodesk.com/index.php/fakeorfoto/

I got 10 out of 12 :sweat_smile::stuck_out_tongue:

The ones I got wrong I second guessed myself, this one is easier than the original imo.

2

"Twelve out of twelve answers are correct. Excellent-- a perfect score and a superior performance. " Yeah, pretty easy.

3

ā€œEleven out of twelve answers are correct. Excellent - you have a good eye!ā€

The blinds got me.

The first version of the test was pure stank!

4

11/12

the ice in the glass got me.

5

The Results

Twelve out of twelve answers are correct. Excellent-- a perfect score and a superior performance.

surprised even myself!

6

11 out of 12

The door or whatever it is in the lower left corner got me.. :confused:

/Thomas

7

10 out of 12

the teddy bears and the ice

8

11 of 12, the door got me too ā€¦

Basically I looked if there are a lot of small imperfections, if so itā€™s real. But Iā€™m sure most of these could be done in 3D spending time adding detail.

9

11 out of 12, glass and ice the wrong one. and I canā€™t even remember if I said it was real or cg.

10

Same here. I pretty much flipped a coin.

11

not enough res to make proper judgement imo.

12

Higher res would just make it easiere, and judging from the result which is usally above 10 correct I would say itā€™s easy enough.

/Thomas

13

Agreed.

10/12

14

Oooops, Zero out of twelve answers are correct. The CG artists have done a really great job! Why not try again? But if youā€™re itching to see whatā€™s fake and whatā€™s foto and canā€™t bear to delay gratification, you can check the answers instead.

damn hard:(

15

11 out of 12 correct, and the one I got wrong I thought was CG. It turned out to be real, but definitely had digital touchups.

16

12/12, wasnt too hard.

The ice one even had noise in the shadows, it was one of the more obvious ones to me.

17

11 / 12ā€¦the wood hammer got meā€¦=0

18

11 out of 12
The first image got me - What was I thinking! :frowning:

Preisler

19

Ice dammit

11 out of 12
The ice got me too, although many where touch and go.

20

12/12
these were easier then previous ones. Typically what gives away cg is perfect edges always round without augmentation. Or overexaggerated things like in the glass shot the diffraction was out of place, the others had too much ambient occlusion in it.
The bulb one was interesting, the actual bulb didnt have much of anything, looked very flat.