Anyone using the dome light regularly? I played with it back when it came out, but haven’t done much since.
If you use it, care to post some samples?
Anyone using the dome light regularly? I played with it back when it came out, but haven’t done much since.
If you use it, care to post some samples?
I haven’t any answer to this but I would like also to know the interest of it!
what are the differences between the dome light and just an environement setting for light. they make very soft lighting perhaps more shadows with dome light?
Priad, the dome light creates raytraced area shadows, while the skylight is GI light and shadows depend on GI settings.
So dome light casts very fine shadows on every detail, but it needs high enough subdivs to be noise free, resulting in high rendertimes.
I never used it in a real project, only for testing when it was new ![]()
humm.. ok I were on the way no? ![]()
Ah. I was under the impression people were using it in some cases as a substitute for GI.
Actually it is a substitute for a skylight. It is basically what Ambient Occlusion would be. GI would mean that the light is bouncing around, which neither the dome light nor Ambient Occlusion do.
It´s a completely different approach tho…as ambient occlusion is only geometry based and not light- or gi-based.
Greetings,
Thorsten
Ok, let’s try to gather all these opinions into one thought, cuz I’m already getting confused.
Here’s how I see it - tell me if I’m wrong:
The vray dome light is a light that simulates the old traditional dome light method in that light comes from all directions inward to simulate GI.
It is different from other lights in that it does not obey the vray global light/GI settings. It traces rays from all directions inward until it “hits a wall”. At that point it casts an area shadow and ceases bouncing.
It differs from the old light dome method in that it is directional, allowing it to simulate a directional sun and GI simultaneously.
It gives a similar look to ambient occlusion, but because it is still based on the environmental “light”, it is not truly AO.
Is this close?
I don’t blame you for being confused. While the method of doing ambient occlusion is different, the result is identical. You can achieve Ambient Occlusion a number of ways: using an irradiance map on the primary bounce and none on the second, using a light dome, etc… Not sure what you mean by Geometry based. Basically AO just implies that you are looking where the geometry is occluding the Ambient light (or skylight). Maybe that is what you mean by geometry. But trust me, they are the same, since a shadow is an occlusion of light. The old dome lights with 64 light sources shadow mapping is the same deal. You could technically call that an Ambient Occlusion. That is what they used on Gollum in two towers. I think it was first used in Pearl Harbor. But I may be wrong. Either way, they called it Ambient Occlusion way back then.
http://www.andrew-whitehurst.net/amb\_occlude.html
One thing to keep clear CCS is that AO and the Skylight have nothing to do with GI, no matter what people tell you. They give you the “look” of GI, but without light bouncing around, you get no GI.
This image was produce purley from the dome light … i think its a fantastic edition to vray but has its limitations.
Ok…
Followup then.
Is it faster than GI? (Would seem it would be)
Is it redundant to run a dome light + GI ? (Would seem so, although I see people are doing this)
Not that it can’t be used without GI but
We have found it works well as a skylight replacement, when used with “store with arradiance map” and pretty high sub divisions it can clean up some GI artifacts without adding much to the render times. Haven’t tried it with just lightcache but it sounds like thats what Vlado was eluding to.
Yeah I remember that post too.
Which takes me back to being completely baffled.
I guess I understand that he made it for a specific case. But being that it is called a “dome light”, that makes me think of the old dome arrays we used to make, and their whole purpose was fake GI…
So, if not a replacement for GI, and it’s not faster, then I suppose that would explain why I haven’t heard much about it.
It’s better than skylight ![]()
When we are able to map a hdri to it it will be even better
Here’s two images, one rendered with skylight and imap/qmc at “very low”
preset. The second imap/qmc at “very low” and a dome light (saved
with imap 64 subs)
You can use the dome light with GI quite successfully.
Usually, most of the fine shadow details in exterior scenes come from the skylight, while GI effects are a lot smoother.
When you use the irradiance map to represent the skylight, you need high settings to get good detail and even so, this may take a lot of time.
With the dome light, you leave the details to the light, while the irradiance map only has to take care of the more smooth secondary illumination. In this way, you can get a better-looking image in less time.
The real advantage of the dome light will be obvious when you can use a HDR image to map it - in this case, it will produce much cleaner results that GI, because it will put more samples in the brighter parts of the map, instead of doing uniform sampling.
Best regards,
Vlado
i do moving object animations most of the time and use domelight (without GI) in all projects.
its fast and flicker-free.
easy to setup with only a single quality setting.
it never surprises you with artifacts after a night of rendering.
i use GI only in interiors with bounced light.
Sorry rerender but testing with such settings is not really fair.
Here are my tests:
Imo, using dome light with store with ir map is useless, because that is exactly what normal skylight is… That is also ‘stored’ with the ir map. In the dome light you have to set the subdivs, even when using store=ON. So you need to control ir map hsph AND dome light subdivs = more work. Plus it renders longer. You also loose the advantage of the raytraced shadows.
Dome lights can be usefull in situations where the GI takes ages to render because you need fine GI detail. In that case, using a domelight can help alot. Instead of using ir map with skylight to compute shadows, now the domelight creates these. The first bounce will then be computed with ir map (this first bounce was the second bounce when using skylight!).
A good use imo would be a dome light with store=off, and first bounce IR map, and dimmed second bounces. This would be very similar to a normal skylight rendering with first and secondary GI, but with very fine (fake) GI detail coming from the dome light area shadows. Because the main part of lighting is already taken care of by the dome light, you don’t need very high ir map settings (like you usually don’t use very high secondoray bounce settings when using skylight+irmap+qmc).
like this:
skylight(1.0)+irmap(1.0)+qmcGI(0.8 )
Dome light(1.0)+irmap(1.0)+qmcGI(0.35)
Rendertimes are of course much higher, but if you would want this detail with only skylight, you would need very high GI settings, resulting in even higher rendertimes.
edit: seems I was making my post while vlado already replied…
Ambient Occlusion works basically like this :
From the point of the geometry you are processing you are shooting rays in random directions (within a defined cone). When you hit any other geometry within a defined range in one ray the point is darkened. if a lot of rays hit other geometry it´s further darken till it gets black in extreme cases. The result is NOT identical with GI or Domelight rendering..AND you got Total control over the distribution of shadowed parts as you can define a min and max radius, bias etc. Another big advantage is that you dont have to trace 128 shadowed lights, but it´s rather similar to a glossy reflection (computation wise).
Refer to this thread : as we had a long discussion about why not to confuse true AO with GI or Domelight rendering :
http://www.chaosgroup.com/forum/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=11245&highlight=ambient+occlusion
Dieter also posted a comparison of an AO pass and a GI pass on our b-class interior renderings.
Greetings,
Thorsten
Can you explain how put a HDR in the dome light?
Or it’s just an hdr in the environment or reflexion slot?
regards