comparison renders

[DaForce]

On it

[DaForce]

Ok, well havnt done much to it.. its not all texture. but man it sure is ALOT cleaner and less noisy than the vray render posted above. Will finish it off later match the camera angle better and see how it goes.



Oh yeah machine specs.

AMD X2 4400
2GB ram
Rendering for 20mins

[jujubee]

I think you forgot to reduce your size a little muhahaha.

[DaForce]

oh yeah his renders are significantly smaller... LOL

ok will fix that up later as well.

[Morbid Angel]

and run it through noise reduction proggie

[Frances]

Re: comparison renders

I saw this over on the maxwell forum. That whole thing is really getting annoying. The maxwellians still want to say that they can compare that bloated beast of a render engine to other production engines.

Here's an idea - quit insulting people who use Maxwell by lumping them all together. From what I gather, this was simply an excersize in creating similar conditions, not a demonstration of Maxwell's production-worthiness.

[phildlight]

I'm all for comparisons, but you have to post the settings for each engine along with the render time and machine specs. Posting an image with 5 different render engines with no explanation, and obvious differences in quality is just asking for trouble.

It's great isma want's to compare engines like this, and it might be very useful, but without some more detail, it's pretty much useless!

I'm not trying to insult anyone, nor generalize people, and I'm certainly not the first person to use the "maxwellians" term. Furthermore, there is a lot of the same on the maxwell side too.

Sorry if I insulted anyone.

[Morbid Angel]

maxwellians started first

[DaForce]

Updated render
20mins PPT
Athlon X2 4400
2GB
Same resolution as the maxwell tests and ALOT less noise.

[jujubee]

A little on the yellow side but hot diggity damn!

@Frances. I agree some people here are very partisan and do put down Maxwell users but I don't see it too much in this thread. I don't think it was fair/objective for that person to come to conclusions without posting his settings. It's a very one-sided study and can lead people down a biased path (no pun intended.)

[Da_elf]

can we just choose where to post for this topic either here or free

[siliconbauhaus]

nice one daforce

[siliconbauhaus]

@Frances. I agree some people here are very partisan and do put down Maxwell users but I don't see it too much in this thread. I don't think it was fair/objective for that person to come to conclusions without posting his settings. It's a very one-sided study and can lead people down a biased path (no pun intended.)

I totally agree with juju.....besides there are just as many pillocks over at the maxwell forum dissing on vray

[jujubee]

Mmmm.

@daforce - you have caustics and m-blur enabled? I take it Maxwell enables it by default. Wonder how that would impact results...

[DaForce]

No I didnt.

I will render it tomorrow.. just about to hit the sack.