New PC

I refused to listen to better suggestions, now :)[quote=“svetlozar.draganov, post:11, topic:42701, username:svetlozar.draganov”]
think something like this would of given the same or even tiny bit better performance and less power draw for the same price or even less as the dell

http://pcpartpicker.com/p/Cn34P6 approx. $1500

CPU - Intel Core i7-4790K 4.0GHz Quad-Core Processor
CPU Cooler     - Cooler Master Hyper 212 EVO 82.9 CFM Sleeve Bearing CPU Cooler
Motherboard - Asus SABERTOOTH Z97 MARK2 ATX LGA1150 Motherboard
Memory - Corsair Vengeance Pro 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR3-1600 Memory
Corsair Vengeance Pro 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR3-1600 Memory
Storage - Samsung 840 EVO 250GB 2.5" Solid State Drive
Video Card     - MSI GeForce GTX 760 2GB TWIN FROZR
Case - Fractal Design Define R4 (Black Pearl) ATX Mid Tower Case
Power Supply - Corsair Professional 650W 80+ Gold Certified Semi-Modular ATX Power Supply
[/quote]

ghz and cores don’t mean much, depends on what architecture they are and whats in the rest of the system.

to give you a rough idea the i7 4790K (stock clock) scores average 11,347 on passmark benchmark where dual xeon 5650 scores average 11,741. if you were to OC the 4790k to even 4.4 GHz i’d bet it’d top the dual 5650 setup.
also with the 4790k you have a newer chipset (z97) , faster ram than the dell system, faster SSD (sata 3 (6GBs)) , better GPU with 2gb vRam and pci-e 3.

i guess the only way to know if someone has a similar systems to these 2 for a comparison but i know which i’d rather have.

But, a poorly optimized scene on the best machine would run slower than a highly optimized scene on a slower machine. It seems both machines in question are comparable to each other, and I already made the purchase, so now I am going to spend my energy becoming a scene optimization ninja.

I don’t want to start a debate here. However, recently I’ve asked to perform a rendering bench mark ( I was considering a new system ) between my old xeon x5650 2.66 12 core and the new 24 core e-5 2697v2. The result? it was exactly twice as fast. Yes newer technology is better, but imo core per core it is just that similar. (this is bwetween xeons though) for i7 the less more powerful cores are true.

It will be hard to say based on benchmark tests alone, they do perform better, and in fact single more powerful cores excel at things like simulations for example.

For me though, in rendering i7 3930 (stock) performs slightly less then xeon 5650, though being at a higher clock at default.

it’s running great, but renderings are pretty slow.


you’ve got 12 cores and only 12 threads, is hyperthreading turned off? that would explain the difference between yours and the top result.
You shouldn’t be surprised about the quadro.

I didn’t do anything, so where do I look? Is it a sytem thing or a MAX thing?[quote=“glorybound, post:12, topic:45716, username:glorybound”]
you’ve got 12 cores and only 12 threads, is hyperthreading turned off? that would explain the difference between yours and the top result.
You shouldn’t be surprised about the quadro.
[/quote]

or, is it a BIOS thing?

Hyper threading is determined by a Bios setting. Take a look in there…should be a simple yes/no toggle.

Another way to check if it’s on is too look at the resource monitor tab in windows’ task manager. How many CPU graphs are shown?

there are 12… should I be seeing 24?

yeah. that should give you an extra boost of 30% or so.

brilliant!

Funny HT would come disabled by default.

I thought so… I should have known, so I can image most wouldn’t have had a clue to enable it.

That is a very interesting benchmark there. Look how similar the mildly overclocked single-CPU 3930k system is, and would cost less or the same to build. I’m running mine at 4ghz, with 32GB RAM. The new 5960X will be 8-core and should reach 4ghz as well, with decent cooling. So you’ll get most likely a better score for less or the same money with that, and with a much simpler consumer system the individual components are far easier and cheaper to replace if needed.

I suspect this is because your xeons are previous generation, not current. As someone else posted earlier, the actual architecture makes a difference when comparing these chips. It’s not just the clock speed or number of cores.

It looks like you got a decent system for the price but I still wonder about the drawbacks and whether or not it’s worth it for such a mild improvement over a single-processor consumer system. And I actually wonder how a properly (4ghz) overclocked 3930k or 4930k would compare, at the same price-point… I think I will run a benchmark when I’m back in the office.

I’m the same - if I can get the same overall grunt but in a single cpu machine I’d rather that for all the programs that have multithreaded limitations.

Oh god, I just noticed by running the same cinebench test that IT at my job really doesn’t do a good job when it comes down to setting up their computers. I’ve been working more than a year on a computer that also has hyperthreading disabled…1.44x slower, that could’ve saved me A LOT of time.

ouch…

I asked them, turns out they do it on purpose because of this:
-Hyperthreading is only interesting when a few cores are used
-when they are all in use, the computer works faster when it’s disabled
-for daily use (not rendering) it’s better this is disabled

:face_with_spiral_eyes::face_with_spiral_eyes::face_with_spiral_eyes::face_with_spiral_eyes::face_with_spiral_eyes:

hah… oh dear. just run a simple benchmark render comparing with and without HT. will solve the issue within 5 mins… one would hope, anyway!