OBJ ID Showing Up Greyscale in Multi-EXR

My obj id pass is coming out as greyscale when I render to a multi-channel exr.
If I render separate exrs per channel, it shows up correctly.
Here is a comparison in Nuke. (the lineup is changed because the frame numbers are different, but you can still see the greyscale vs rgb)
I am rendering in Maya 2025, with VRay 6.2.0

why not just use cryptomatte? sorry I don’t know the solution to this issue.

That’s expected. Multichannel exrs hold the integer data rather than normalizing it to RGB colors. There’s an option to write the separate EXRs as integers, too (Render Settings > Image format options > EXR > Write integer IDs (non-multi-channel files only)).

@Morbid_Angel That obj ID represents a bunch of different geo and materials. So cryptomattes would be a lot of clicking.

@hermit.crab Sorry, I dont get why this is the expected result for an OBJID pass. The mutlEXR saves of other aovs with RGB info.
Are you saying the OBJID pass that I have should be usable?
Do I just need to key for values on each of the different OBJIDs?

It’s more precise than colors.

Yes, it’s perfectly usable. One way to extract the data as a mask is to use an Expression node (check screenshot); Grade’s white/black point and the Keyer node should also work.