V-Ray wizzard - request for contribution

So I have this idea of creating a V-Ray “wizard”, which would be script that asks the user some questions (e.g. what kind of scene is being rendered - interior, exterior, animation, product design; what kind of quality is required - preview, draft, print, animation; what effects are needed - GI, caustics etc; what resolution will be the final image and things like that) and then adjusts the V-Ray settings accordingly. In short, something like an expert system on V-Ray settings.

While I have some ideas about what questions should be asked, and what settings they would result in, any input on that would be helpful. In particular, sutiations like, “if I render exterior scenes, I adjust this-and-this setting like so”, or “if I have lots of glossy objects in the scene, I do this-and-this”. The script could even go as far as rendering a few test images to measure the performance of different settings, and choosing the optimal one, or rendering a few tests for you to pick the one you like most.

So, any input on this would be appreciated!

Best regards,
Vlado

Heya vlado, I’m working on a settings collector at the moment which probably does quite similar except it’s collecting rather than setting - If there’s some dumb donkey work you need done on it or if we could make the two compatible if it was beneficial…

I think this is a super idea! Finally a way for new users like me to get some results right out of the box instead of reading and digesting the manual and trawling this forum!

Absolutely - it might be worth doing a bit of a compiled “best of” from the forum to get some of the theory in one place though so rather than just relying on something like vlados wizard, you can get your own understanding of why he’s chosen certain settings and what difference they make - There’s a pretty overhwleming amount of information scattered around the discussions here :smile:

I think the vray wikki is doing just this :slight_smile:

Yep, I agree. The purpose of the wizard is slightly different… ideally it would save a lot of test renderings and will allow you to set up your scene much faster.

Best regards,
Vlado

Superrrr…

I cant wait for that Vlado :slight_smile:

Hi,
I like the idea of the test render thing to find the best settings. Something you could fire at the renderfarm to see what would be best quality/speed before you start your final render. But it would already be interesting to have a diagramm of what the wizard would do for certain situations.
In any case it should output a logfile where I can see what it did change. I hate the idea of a wizard that changes settings somewhere without telling me. Perhaps it could even print out why it has changed certain settings.

Best Regards,

Dieter

instead if a (always annoying) multi-page wizard i’d suggest a smart, dynamic single page dialog/html style form.
wizards are very 1995 and even microsoft tries to avoid them by now.

i think this could be a good idea.
it would be a nice feature if you could send an image off to render in “evaluation” mode that returned images (or part of) that used settings either side of what you sent the original image at. eg if you send an image off with an irmap of -5,-3 the :evaluation script could return image done at -6,-4 and -4,-2 to see if there are any gains in rendertime/quality.
For testing materials the :evaluation script could test out glossy subdivision settings and AA settings to see which would produce the best image.

if you could also save changes to the settings so that they get a bit “tweeked” to your needs. like say exposure settings slightly diferent but get saved so next time you run the wizard again it’s now uses those tweeks you made.

joconnell:
How is that coming along mate? Im curious to see how its turning out.
I seriously think the vray scene settings exporter that you are working on should be implement officially into Vray as i mentioned in the wish list. Vlado are you in agreement ? :slight_smile:

Vlado:
Wicked idea mate, this will really make those maxwell chumps weep when not only can we RENDER faster but we can setup a scene just as quick as them :wink:

Maybe an idea would be to setup 4 or so differnet types of scenes. (interior, exterior, animation, product design)
Then give these to a group of forum goers and get them to set them up as they would normally. Maybe some people going for a fast render approach and some people going for a quality approach.
Then you would take these scenes back and compare settings against speed and quality.
Or if the “vray scene settings exporter” was working you could just get the exported settings and use those.
If just think you would get a better result and more accurate settings.
Anyway just a thought :smile:

This idea reminds me a lot of how lightscape used to work which has a wizard for the type of scene you were setting up. Great idea!. The only thing i didnt like about the wizard was remembering the decisions I had already made in earlier steps

I think the wizard should perform similar to the curret presets but store more values such as resolution, general rendering settings and max environment . Possibly instead of a wizard, have ‘tree’ kind of graphical layout with each decision forming a fork in this tree. Every decision is visible with the options collapsing once a decision has been made so that in the end you have a simple representation of what you want to achieve.

eg: interior → daylight → PPT → Fast settings → print resolution

or interior → evening → Lightcache → high quality → screen resolution

or exterior → daytime → animation → QMC → DVD(PAL) → precalc

or exterior → daytime → animation → QMC → DVD(PAL) ->use stored maps

say if i clicked on “precalc” an expanded list should pop-up presenting the other options so that I can easily render out the final frames after doing the precalculations

I think this whole system could be great, but it if doesnt work flawlessly, it could make things more difficult for people to do what they want (just look at all of the things MS introduced to make windows “EASIER” to use, and avoid what they have done)

Really good idea, but i think stay away from evil wizards! (my 2cents). I think dont be afraid to be influenced by things that work in Maya, Lightwave etc etc etc

PS: with animations, i think promting the user for where to store the precalced light files etc would be cool so that we dont forget to put them somewhere that all of the farm machines can access!

WHAT A GREAT IDEA!!!

That would be the next step to the “render-cool-scene-Button”. :lol:

Good idea, ineed!

At risk of being flamed, can I differ from all the other responses on this thread?

I think this is a terrible idea - it will basically allow any Tom, Dick or Harry to produce good results. We have invested a lot of time and money (and stress) in learning how Vray works from the ground up - its working for us, and gives us a competative edge. If a ‘wizzard’ was there, any old Cad-monkey could produce a good image.

Yes, it initially sounds nice, but from a purely commercial point of view, “No way! Don’t do it!!!”

HE HO … !!!

i allready do get very good results… :!: :lol:

Well nice idea Vlado..

another thing to think of… for animations, best settings can very much differ..

is there a way, to optimise settings over an animation, meaning, to change parameters smothely ?

of course, the wizard would have to analyse the animation at varying frames, but maybe … ?

nice idea. imo

Tom

I would like an addition for rendering animations.It would work like this:

Prior to calculating imaps for a ani path it would run along the animation path and determine at which frames new geometry is seen and then calculating the least amount of frames needed to expose all geometry. This could optimize the practice of rendering every nth frame for imaps.

Tricky…I don’t quite understand your thinking with that response.
I believe anything that VLADO decides could make workflow easier and more efficient out of the box helps everyone. Sorry if you had to take so long learning the ins and outs of what works and how it works. Really that is a good thing that you do understand all that because it allows you to tweak “presets” that way you like. I don’t think you will loose any business dude. I think it will definitely make VRAY much more marketable against Plugins such as “Maxwell”…which in my opinion is no match…sure it’s great looking and all, but you have to tweak the h3!! outta it to get it even close to render times like VRAY.

Tricky - One thing about it though is if the settings are really easy to get for a nice render, you’ll have far more time to spend on the things that matter like material settings, light placement and colours. Maxwell is nice in the sense that the materials are more of a formality so you can concentrate more on your composition and photography.

Another way of thinking about it is theres a well known post company in soho where the head of 3d apparently went through a period of not hiring anyone that was better than him in an effort to artificially keep himself at the top. Not sure if this was true or not but if it was, he was keeping himself from learning what the better people knew and improving himself. Competition is good because it’ll keep pushing you to improve things and be a better 3d op overall.

When it gets to the point where it’s really easy to get a photorealistic render then what will be the things that make the difference? It’ll be traditional skills like composition, editing, animation, direction and concept - You’re probably a more artistic person than “any old cad monkey” so these things will rpboably come far more naturally to you than them and that will become the new difference putting your work above theirs :slight_smile: